Best Pizza in Emigsville

Taste the Tradition of Sicily
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

Featuring

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
If there's one thing that can fix anything, it's pizza. And at The Heart of Sicily, we know how to make the best pizza around. Our dough is made fresh every day, and we use only the finest ingredients for a taste that will leave you wanting more. Our shop is open 7 days a week, features lunch specials from 11-3 pm, and offers a convenient drive thru for pick up needs!

Catering Is Our Specialty

Catering Is Our Specialty
The Heart of Sicily is the perfect catering solution for your next party! We offer a wide variety of catering trays, including subs, salads, pasta trays and more. Our food is made fresh and requires 24 hours notice, so be sure to order ahead of time! Our team is dedicated to providing you with delicious food and excellent customer service. Let us take care of everything so you can focus on having a great time!

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Heart of Sicily has the best customer service and ingredients. We always order an extra cheese pizza on Friday night and they hook it up! The cheese is thicker than the crust! We tried the calzone tonight, and it may have been the best calzone I’ve had in years! I highly recommend this place!

Brandy E.

Brandy E.

The food is excellent here! I have been here twice and each time it was amazing. I ordered extra bacon for my sub and I got so much bacon I could have put it on three subs! The bacon that they use is so good! I got it extra crispy.. Just the way I love it!

Jonathan T.

Jonathan T.

FANTASTIC IN EVERY WAY POSSIBLE! MIKE (owner) is very family oriented and his employees Are just like family. You won't be disappointed!!!

Kenneth C.

Kenneth C.

This has to be one of my favorite restaurants. The service is great along with the waitress we had. Very friendly and welcoming. Really is the Best pizza in York. I will definitely be returning.

Shay S.

Shay S.

Such a delicious little pizza shop!!! We moved Emigsville about two weeks ago and have eaten here three times already. Not once were we disappointed and very much enjoyed out meals. Pizza is on point, Salads are on point and customer service is awesome!!!

Benjamin M.

Benjamin M.

Amazing food! The subs, pizza, and Stromboli are soooo good!!! I order a turkey n provolone sub almost daily.. also their grilled chicken salads with the house dressing is also really good! Great employees and the owner is a very good person! I’ve never had a complaint, and I’ve literally ordered atleast a few times a week since I moved to Emigsville back in august.. I’m addicted to the subs and Stromboli!! The marina sauce is also very good! I highly recommend this pizza shop!

Brittany B.

Brittany B.

The Heart of Sicily Rewards

The Heart of Sicily Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Our Pizzeria

Our Pizzeria
Stop by our place and let your taste buds travel to the charming hills of an Italian countryside! Our long history with pizza making has inspired us to take a spin on traditional recipes.

Indulge Your Senses

Indulge Your Senses
Indulge in mouth-watering calzones, stomboli, gyros, wings & more that use only freshest ingredients from local organic farmers. Craving something special? Try one of Mamma's Specialty Pizzas - like Supreme or Chicken Parmesan – guaranteed satisfaction for even the pickiest foodie! Get ready for deliciousness: just south of downtown Emigsville!

Frequently asked questions

Our location